Русская версияУкраинская версияМолдавская версияГреческая версияАнглийская версия

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Constantinople’s claims have brought forth bitter fruits of schism in the world Orthodoxy

Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk: Constantinople’s claims have brought forth bitter fruits of schism in the world Orthodoxy
Version for print
11 November 2021 year 17:27

On November 11, 2021, an international conference on the Conciliarity of the Church: Theological, Canonical and Historical Dimensions opened in the Kiev Theological Academy. 

In his message of greetings to the organizers and participants of the forum, Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, chairman of the Department for External Church Relations of the Moscow Patriarchate, stated as topical the issue of primacy of the Patriarchate of Constantinople, which has become an apple of discord in the world Orthodoxy. 

“As is known, beginning from the mid-11th century, this Patriarchate has occupied the first place of honour in the family of the Local Orthodox Churches. It was endowed with it due to historical circumstances”, Metropolitan Hilarion reminded the conference, “For many centuries, Rome, as the capital city of the empire, had been the first see in Christendom. After Emperor Constantine founded a new capital city on the Bosporus shores, the Second Ecumenical Council adopted a resolution that equalized the New Rome - Constantinople, as “the city of the tsar and synkletos”, with old Rome. Owing to this decision confirmed by the Council of Chalcedon in its Canon 28, Constantinople occupied the second place after Rome in the diptych of the Churches. However, when in 1054 a rupture happened in the communion between Constantinople and Rome, the primacy in the family of the Eastern Orthodox Churches automatically as it were went to Constantinople. But it was the primacy in honour, not in power, and the Patriarchate of Constantinople was perceived as “the first among equal”. 

However, in our days, theologians in the Church of Constantinople insist that the Primate of this Church is “first without equal”, the DECR chairman pointed out. They declare that “he can reshape the boundaries of the Local Churches at his own discretion and, that he can invade into the boundaries of Local Churches and introduce his own order it them and arrange his own stauropegia; that he is the highest appellation instance for all the Churches; that by the stroke of a pen he can abolish a millions-strong Church that has over one hundred bishops, over twelve thousand parishes, over two hundred fifty monasteries and transfer her rights and name to a schismatic structure; that he can declare a self-ordained man a lawful bishop and ‘return the rank’ to a man who has never had such a rank or have lost it due to his falling into a schism”. In addition, according to their opinion, the Patriarch of Constantinople ostensibly has the exclusive rights to all the Orthodox diaspora. 

“In 1950, Schema-archimandrite Sofroniy (Sakharov), now ranked among saints by the Church of Constantinople, called all these claims “a heresy of Constantinople’s papism”. He predicted that sooner or later this heresy would lead to a schism in the world Orthodoxy. Alas, the prophecy of Starets Sofroniy has come true, and today we are harvesting the bitter fruits of those claims of Constantinople which were yet in germ in his time”, Metropolitan Hilarion stated. 

He is convinced that the threats to Orthodoxy resulting from the actions of the Patriarch of Constantinople demand a wide conciliar reflection by the hierarchy, clergy, monastics and laity. 

“I hope that today’s conference held in the Kiev Theological Academy will make its contribution to the comprehension of the challenges encountered today by the Orthodox Church”, His Eminence Hilarion stressed and wished God’s help to all the participants in the conference and peace and prosperity to the much-suffering and persecuted Ukrainian Orthodox Church.

DECR Communication Service/Patriarchia.ru

Version: Russian, Greek

Materials on the theme

Metropolitan Hilarion of Budapest and Hungary: Vatican concedes to liberals on the issue of same-sex couples [Interview]

Отношения Московского и Константинопольского Патриархатов в 1960-е — начале 1970-х годов по материалам архива Отдела внешних церковных связей [Article]

Патриарх Варфоломей повел себя крайне непоследовательно [Article]

Metropolitan Jonathan of Tulchyn and Bratslav characterized the words of Patriarch Bartholomew, who condemned the confessional feat of the Ukrainian hierarchs, as blasphemous

Holy Synod calls upon international community to speak out in defence of persecuted Ukrainian Orthodox Church

Comments by DECR Communication Service on Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople’s speech at World Policy Conference (Abu Dhabi, 9 December 2022) [Documents]

Address of the DECR chairman Metropolitan Anthony of Volokolamsk at the meeting of the UN Security Council [Article]

ЖУРНАЛЫ Священного Синода от 7 июня 2022 года [Documents]

Lectures on Orthodox ecclesiology held in Belarusian Exarchate’s dioceses

Патриаршая проповедь в день памяти святителя Петра после Литургии в Успенском соборе Московского Кремля [Patriarch : Sermons]

Archbishop Theodosius of Sebastia visited the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission

Patriarch Kirill gives his blessing to offering up fervent prayers for archpastors and clerics of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church striving to preserve church unity

Archbishop Theodosios of Sebastia: The Orthodox Church is subjected to unprecedented persecution and violence in Ukraine

Archbishop Theodosius of Sebastia: the oppression to which the Ukrainian Orthodox Church is subjected is unjust and cannot be justified or accepted in any form

The Serbian Patriarch pointed to the escalating intolerance of the Ukrainian authorities towards the Ukrainian Orthodox Church

Отношения Московского и Константинопольского Патриархатов в 1960-е — начале 1970-х годов по материалам архива Отдела внешних церковных связей [Article]